【My Mothers Friend 5】
Other People’s Diaries
Diaries
While reading Annie Ernaux’s Simple Passion, I often caught myself mistaking it for a diary. The memoir details an illicit affair in prose that feels startlingly immediate, full of particulars that seem to surface in real time: a skirt in a Benetton shop; a list of fortune-tellers in the telephone book; the faded lettering of a plaque that reads PASSAGE CARDINET, near where the author sought a clandestine abortion years before. Yet I was continually made aware that time had passed, and this was last year’s love seen through this year’s eyes: “From September last year,” Ernaux writes, near the beginning, “I did nothing else but wait for a man: for him to call me and come around to my place.” The details of this “most violent and unaccountable reality” have been refracted and altered, distilled into a remarkable book.
I recently read A Girl’s Story, Ernaux’s 2020 memoir of another doomed and passionate love—her first, in the summer of 1958—and was struck by her description of the process by which she reconstructed her former self, the diligence with which she studiedthis young “girl of ’58.” Ernaux googles her summer-camp bunkmates and considers pretending to be a journalist so she can call them up and ask about herself. She looks at a photograph of her long-lost lover’s great-grandchildren. While reading an old diary, and letters she sent to a classmate, she recognizes certain falsenesses in them—pretensions, lies, self-deceptions. The quotations from books she copied down in 1958 now strike her as a more direct means of access to her state of mind then. All memoir involves time travel, and yet Ernaux, as she twists and turns, trying to cross the schisms between her various selves, manages to create what feels like a new tense—a literary time zone that can hold it all at once.
In our Spring issue, the Reviewpublished some of the source material on which Ernaux based Simple Passion: selections from her real diaries from 1988, which describe her affair with a married diplomat from the Soviet Union. Here is that violent and unaccountable reality, recorded at a distance of mere hours. Many entries are short, factual, engaged with the torment of love and logistics: “Last night he called. I was sleeping. He wanted to come around. Not possible. (Éric here.) Restless night, what to do with this desire?” Others are breathless and breezy: “I realized that I’d lost a contact lens. I found it on his penis. (I thought of Zola, who lost his monocle between the breasts of women.)” To read them is to encounter something like a pentimento, the revelation of writing underneath other writing—a quality that already suffuses so much of her work. We can, of course, marvel at what Ernaux was able to make of these entries in Simple Passion. But they offer their own distinct and potent pleasures, the rare, delightful, occasionally shocking intimacies of reading someone else’s private thoughts.
To mark the appearance of Ernaux’s diaries, the Reviewhas been asking writers and artists to share pages from their own. Yesterday on our website, we published the first in the series: part of the poet Elisa Gonzalez’s 2018 journal, which documents the aftermath of an affair and a marriage. Reading them now, she, too, had some distance from this former self. “I used to accept, unquestioningly, that pleasure was fleeting,” she writes in a postscript. “but now I think it has an afterlife, during which we integrate it into all the griefs we also feel.”
These diaries feel like gifts, or offerings, that are unlike any other kind of writing. There is, as Ernaux herself writes in a brief introduction, “a truth in those pages that differed from the one to be found in Simple Passion—something raw and dark, without salvation, a kind of oblation.”
Sophie Haigney is the web editor of The Paris Review.
Search
Categories
Latest Posts
Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for January 30
2025-06-27 03:16Taylor Swift's 'Lavender Haze' video contains Easter eggs, of course
2025-06-27 03:14This burger with a face (and teeth!) is freaking everybody out
2025-06-27 02:52Sri Lanka vs. Australia 2025 livestream: Watch 1st ODI for free
2025-06-27 02:24Popular Posts
11 Tech Products That Were Supposed to Fail... But Didn't
2025-06-27 03:52Football manager's rage
2025-06-27 02:25Featured Posts
Samsung Unpacked event livestream: Watch live now
2025-06-27 03:07Samsung Galaxy S23 vs S22: Specs, price, and more.
2025-06-27 02:3512 gifts for your friend who loves Netflix
2025-06-27 02:21Popular Articles
Meta says some AGI systems are too risky to release
2025-06-27 03:58Juul removed fruity flavors but teens actually like mint
2025-06-27 03:36Courtney Cox Instagrams a perfectly
2025-06-27 03:35Best MacBook deal: Save $200 on 2024 M3 MacBook Air
2025-06-27 01:51Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates.
Comments (972)
Expressing Aspiration Information Network
Clean energy projects soared in 2016 as solar and wind got cheaper
2025-06-27 03:34Pursuit Information Network
Please enjoy videos of Donald Trump being publicly booed yet again
2025-06-27 02:52Wise Information Network
Football manager's rage
2025-06-27 02:00Information Information Network
'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for January 31
2025-06-27 01:55Mark Information Network
Best early Prime Day Roomba deals: Newest Roombas on sale at Amazon
2025-06-27 01:27